MARIAH vs MIMI:
Really, there are two types of Mariah. There is the Mariah who warbled power ballads and insiduous dance tunes throughout most of the 90s before going a bit crazy (Britney is so behind the times) and making the biggest comeback this side of Take That. Then there is Mimi Mariah, who insists on having guest rappers on everything and going all a bit hip hop. Which granted, has served her just as well in recent years as her old jeans and sweater on a swing in videos persona, but has left me colder than a witches tit in November. Mariah launched onto the scene back in 1990 with the epic debut single Vision of Love, which perfectly showcased her astounding vocal range and showed that she could (co)write a melodic tune up with the best of them. I fell instantly in love. I spent a fortune on importing her debut album (which i later retitled Visions) and devoured the mix of balladry (Love Takes Time, I Don't Wanna Cry) and pure pop tunes (All In Your Mind remains an all time fave along with funktastic There's Got To Be A Way). Her second album barely a year later was more of the same leading off with 70s inspired Emotions, more ballads (Can't Let Go) and the excellent spiritual follow up to There's Got To Be A Way, Make It Happen. Once again, this song showed that Mariah could pull off a bit of restraint and rule the dancefloor in a way that was completely more acceptable than say, Celine doing Misled (though i like that song too...). I was all ready for Mariah to release the highlight of her second album, You're So Cold, (a down and dirty slice of prince-esque pop) but instead she released a cover of I'll Be There with Trey Lorenz which actually sealed her fate as an international superstar. Her next few albums in retrospect, were a slow and subtle shift to the more hip hop orientated sound she would come to adopt, but kept the pop sensibilities that I loved. Tracks like Hero, Dreamlover, Fantasy and my all time fave Mariah song, Always Be My Baby, competed with Whitney, Janet and Deborah for space on my cd player and often won out. Add into this one of the most enduring Christmas songs in recent memory to be released and I was convinced I would be a Mariah fan for life...
Then Butterfly came along and my interest started to wane ever so slightly. Honey was the first lead off single of hers that I abandoned in a ridiculously short amount of time, and her duet with Brian McKnight (Whenever You Call) was the only track on the album I kept coming back to on a regular basis. A similar tale happened with Rainbow. It was only the nostalgia of treacly ballad Thank God I've Found You that held my interest. What was going on? True, I was going through a big indie college rock phase, but hey I was still spinning Deborah and Kylie, and worshipping at the altar of Steps so it couldn't be that my pop had fizzled out. Still, I had invested so much time in Mariah and she had provided so much enjoyment for me, that i owed it to her to be a bit more faithful (unlike Janet she hasn't burned all her bridges with me :P ). Unfortunately Glitter was a big old mess, but the single Through The Rain was a return to form that I appreciated (even though Charmbracelet was still too hip hop heavy for my liking). Then the whole world liked Mariah again thanks to her emancipation and once again, I was left pondering why one of my favourite acts had experienced such a fall from grace from me...
E=MC2
..Until now. Mariah's latest album is probably my favourite album of hers since Daydream. It's by no means in the classic Mariah mode of old that I adore, but maybe I am mature enough now to accept that she has moved on and so must I. Or perhaps there is enough hint of it in this body of work that it is completely appealing to my nostalgic side. Lead off single Touch My Body is a tongue in cheek slinky groove that wisely keeps Mariah at the centre of the song and hangs back from Timbaland style over production that can overpower lesser artists. It's the reliance on guest rappers and artists that once again do nothing for me - Migrate with T-Pain (who?), the reggae flavoured (but not in a good Jesse/Shayne way) Cruise Control and frankly boring Side Effects could all be left off the album to create a much tighter collection of tunes. I think it was PPG who heard that the very We Belong Together sounding sob fest Bye Bye could be the second single. From an accountants point of view, this is probably a good choice. It's a lovely tune, with a gorgeous restrained vocal from Mariah and a lovely lilting melody. I have no problem with this as a single. It's just that there are a few other songs that could easily be stronger and better single choices. I Stay In Love is probably the most 90s Mariah song here - there is some lovely piano and she starts off the song using the lower register of her voice, which I absolutely adore. It's an incredibly pretty song that sticks in your head and makes me fall in love with her all over again. Plus it makes me want to hug Darren incredibly tightly and that's always a good thing. The incredible That Chick takes inspiration from Michael Jackson's Off The Wall and is a song so brimming with potential (both remix and radio) that I wouldn't be surprised if this was a massive smash all over the world this summer. (And a funky little choreographed dance routine wouldn't go amiss either). Taking me back to the days of perfect summer pop grooves like Make It Happen and Always Be My Baby continues with the very lovely I'll Be Lovin You Long Time. O.O.C is a club banger in the same way that So Cold should've been (though it doesn't really need the annoying bloke rant behind the groove!) I have to say I am preferring Mariahs 70s and 80s influences much more than her hip hop vibes and that is what is making this album work for me in a big way.
Pre-purchase from amazon: Uk or US - stick or twist, the choice is yours...
Check out PPG's alternative perspective here...
15 comments:
Paul, I SWEAR I didn't see this review or know of its existence before I posted mine!
Anyway, this was really interesting to read, and we had some pretty different reactions to some of the songs--I think "Side Effects" is brilliant and you've highlighted a few songs I've kind of been neglecting and have to go back and listen to again now...I like "I Stay In Love," for example, but I've not listened to it a bunch.
I love reviews that force me to go back and reevaluate songs I didn't get before--ones that really make me think/make me appreciate things I didn't pick up on or appreciate before. Especially because I think this will help me like even more of the album. Plus, you've actually listened to her music in the past and can put all this into context!
I'm a little disturbed by the "Touch My Body" MV ...
I think Side Effects is hands down the best song on the album. It's so personal, and it's the first time Mariah really deals with her marriage to Tommy Mottola in a song. It's got an infectious beat and would be a huge hit for Mariah.
I guess people like side effects... I have only heard a couple of songs from the album so far (That Chick and I Stay In Love) and i like both of them a lot. She was hilarious on the Friday Night Project which went a long way to me liking her again too...
Bring back the poodle perm Mariah!
Ben (thetwoofusneedlooknomore)
Hrm. I think I need to listen to this album again then... First impressions, I was very meh. I was in a fairly awful mood when I listened to it though so maybe that had something to do with my mehness.
After reading both yours and PPG's excellent reviews, I agree with you both. The non-standout tracks sort of mush themselves together and you have no idea of the song's title after you hear it. But I hvae to say that "Bye Bye" got me this morning. It is very "We Belong Together", but the added aspect of loss makes it a winner for me. She's going to do very well when/if this is a single. Whether or not it's the next one, that remains to be seen. But I do likey. "I'm That Chick" and the shout out to them Vietnamese hookers "I'll Be Loving U Long Time" are both keepers as well!
what happened to her voice? :S
I’m not trying to hate on Mariah, as I’ve liked most of her past singles, but this CD is mediocre. All of the upbeat songs sound overly similar to “Shake it Off,” and all of the ballads sound the same.
I’m very disappointed in this CD. =(
I just love this album, even with some songs having recycle beats. It’s pretty solid, and better than TEOM, as good as it was. I’ll definetely be buying this on the 15th. I just hope that in the next album she switches up some of her producers and don’t use this much of recycled beats. We love “Classic Mariah” but we don’t wanna get bored either. And I see at least two more number #1’s on the way!
Sorry, but whoever wrote that review is an idiot. T-Pain a nobody. Wow! You obviously don’t know music. Side Effects and Migrate are way better single material than Bye Bye or O.O.C. And I don’t know what clubs you go to, but they obviously suck if you think that would be a banger. HAHAHAHAHA.
Great review! Although I am hugley in doubt that I shall ever buy any new Mariah material, I am currently on my way to check out the Prince-esque track you mentioned. Good times!
Banger? as in the Welsh town?
or Bangers and mash?
PPG ~ I may slowly be coming around to side effects, but it will never be a fave. though maybe it will. I like ballad and dance mariah - a side of hip hop is optional :) Glad you liked the review!!
Totes - disturbed by the sluttiness or disturbed cos you wanna touch her body...
Anon - it probably will be a big hit for Mariah, just not with me. I don't think that will really keep her up at night though :P
Ben # she was aces on FNP. She even had potty mouth alan carr speechless. The audience was gaytastic!!
Adem ~ Oh no! Be unmoody and listen to it again. Though it may not fare well after a roisin live performance!!
Yuri - Bye bye is just gorgeous and whether or not it is next single I will be choosing it as my next single for her! Screw the rest of the world!! Haha. And your hookers joke is deliciously un-pc.
Raffie ~ Maybe it disappeared with the rest of her clothes?? :P
Lukey - fair point. it's different strokes for different folks. i didn't like her last album at all and look how well that did so what do i know?!
Celeste - mixing it up would be fine with me for the next album. I imagine i will be tired of breathy Mariah by then!
Ah Paris, what a little charmer you are. I love how i am totally positive about the album and say a few tracks aren't for me, and i'm an idiot :) What a harsh world you must live in! And Bye Bye IS the next single so someone in Mariah's camp must have gone to the same idiot school as me. :)
Jamietod - ta dude. I needed that after Paris's charming comments :P
Bobs - banger as in what Paris' boyfriends refer to her as on the graffiti on the toilet walls :P
TRUE STORY: I didn't really care much for Mariah until the rest of the free world decided to start hating her... (I have a soft spot for people who shine bright and then fall a little too fast) I decided to get all up in her Glitter from that point on... (seriously, last night a dj saved my life.)
I really just want to hug her.
Seeing her perform BYE BYE on American Idol last night, now I just want to hug that song. Loves it.
As a Kansas boy who loves country music and High School Musical more than he should, I'm hardly a proper critic for all other types of music, but I wanted to throw in how my heart feels about The Emancipated One.
ps. I'm new here.
do you love it??
jimmie.
double ps- something stinks like Paris.
Post a Comment