The X Factor 2010 ~ Week 5: Auditions (Manchester Part 2) + New Joe McElderry single

While waiting for the final auditions to air, I came across Joe McElderry. Not literally of course, that would be wildly inappropriate. No, his new single finally aired on radio. It's called Ambitions and even though I didn't really want him to win X Factor (I still feel he's more musical theatre bound) I was willing to give his solo career a try (The Climb notwithstanding as that was thrust upon whoever won). You know, Leona got the career defining Bleeding Love, Alexandra got the ballsy Bad Boys and even poor Leon got the very overlooked Don't Call This Love. What does Joe get? A cover version. Granted a cover version that the masses won't really know. And it's a fabbo song to be sure. But if you have already heard Donkeyboy's Ambitions, then there is no need to hear Joe's near note for note(ish) cover. Sure, it will probably be gobbled up and lauded an amazing hit. But i'm proper pissed off by this. Donkeyboy deserved to storm the UK with that song and become the pop legends they are in Norway. I only hope they take the money they make and come up with an even better "sophomore" album. I need to take two kalms now before the show starts...
EDIT: It's the morning after and the kalms have worked. I'm still grossly disappointed in the song choice but it's what the world has come to expect from SyCo (repurposing European hits that the general masses won't have heard - and I'm also informed the Leon song was actually a cover and reminded that Shayne Ward got No Promises, another cover) and i'm sure that it will do well for the little tyke (who looks quite nice on the album cover). I'm still sticking with Donkeyboy though...

  • Damian Devine ~ love that "on the last day of auditions", the judges have changed clothes from the outside shots to the inside shots. Perhaps they were sweaty? Amazing. Damian Devine (his real name) looks like the River Island sales rack threw up on him, so it's probably fitting that he "butcher" (ho ho, cos she wore a meat dress don't you know) Poker Face. Well you can't fault his enthusiasm I suppose, even though he comes across like a dvd extra of a failed audition for the character of Kurt on Glee. It's a no. But a nice polite fella. (more "dance" filled auditions follow and all the judges change clothes intermittantly again).
  • Tobias ~ He's 20 and had about 20 jobs. I'm 36 and have only had 6. Good grief. He looks on this as a job interview. He's doing well as he only says his name and he gets a massive scream. Nice hair. He's (daringly) doing the Moulin Rouge version of Your Song and oh, it's quite pleasant. He needs to stop holding his tummy while he sings though. "I'm worried that this will be your 21st job" Simon reasonably states. "I'm punctual" smiles Tobias and a nation falls in love with his cheeky charm. It's a yes. And then even more people get a yes! THIS IS UNPRECENDENTED AND NEVER HAPPENS ON THE X-FACTOR!!! :P (inc some girl whose name I missed but did an exquisite version of You Don't Have To Say You Love Me). (Actually lots of good auditions follow but none get enough time to do them justice).
  • Harry ~ Androgynous 16 year old Harry is the lead singer of a band, who he has clearly ditched for this audition process. Lots of people kiss him before he goes on stage. I thought his mom was going to wet a tissue and dab at his face. He does Stevie Wonder (relevance alert) and I can't help but feel the audience are too quick in Manchester to holler their approval. He's barely done a note and they are screaming. Louis says no cos Harry is too young. This is ridiculous and an X Factor pet peeve of mine. It usually comes from Simon so it's a bit hypocritical when simon says this is a rubbish reason. Harry aka Mini-Mika gets through though.

  • Diva Fever ~ Oh Christ. They liken themselves to Wham and I sort of like them before they've even sung a note. I'm confused by their Whammyness though when they sing Let It Be and are all solomn. it's nice but not particularly exciting. They then get to do Proud Mary instead (relevance alert). "I'm singing for my life cos I'm not having a no" sasses one. ooo get you. It's bloody brilliant. I LOVE THEM. They are my Same Difference for 2010. Louis (not shockingly) leads a trio of yesness!
  • Richard ~ He's obviously this year's DILF. Wella t least it's an improvement of poor dead wife Daniel from a few years back. He's a pub singer and Simon tells him he has one tune to prove himself. Richard looks at him like this is brand new information. He settles on Higher & Higher (relevance alert). It's ok, at least he's more in time than his family's pitiful attempts to clap along. Louis reels out the "you've picked up too many bad habits in the clubs" line that comes up every year. The tears are starting to well. In Richard's eyes not mine. I couldn't care less, though it's a surprising no as there haven't been many non-comedy nos this year. Perhaps this is planning in advance and he is actually scripted to come back next year and prove the judges wrong.
  • Marlon ~ Oh ok, I was wrong about Richard so Marlon gives being this year's DILF a bash. In a horrible t-shirt and a hat he's borrowed from Ortise JLS. He sings Ain't No Sunshine (relevance alert again) and does his own slightly weird version that doesn't sound contemporary at all, though you can see Simon thinking it is amazeballs (though not amazeballs enough to stop munching his nuts). Look, I didn't particularly like it or him but he's obviously through. Danyl 2.0
  • Westlife ~ A new Westlife song is playing in the background and it's wonderfully orchestral, soaring and appropriately inspiring. I can't wait to hear the full version - let's hope the new album gets treated better than their last one :/ So much better than Joe...
NEXT WEEK - BOOTCAMP!!!

8 comments:

  1. I kinda dig Joe's version since it's more of a dance remix but of course, the original version by Donkeyboy is just brilliant on it's own.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Loved the extra snarky sarcasm this time out. They definitely have 1 script and stick to it mercilessly. I'm especially annoyed by all the contradicting statements from 1 contestant to the next about sounding modern or relevant. How many modern and relevant songs do they get to sing in the live rounds anyway.
    Also annoying was when Simon stopped the singers after 5 seconds because it wasn't what he was expecting from the "obviously gay" duo. Camp it up boys! Fun, Fun! Don't try to show me your vocal ability for heaven sake.

    The Westlife snippet sounded good as nearly all their songs do, but production wise it sounds like a step backwards from the more "relevant" direction their last album pointed them. I'm sure I will love it. And I'm sure it will be Top 5 and get no respect and no follow up single.

    My pessimism has never failed me, but I'm sure someday it will.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nothing that good on X Factor other than the camp brilliance of Diva Fever - though did you notice that when they did highlight their vocals Simon got bored and thought, I want them flouncing around!! As you would say, amazing!

    Joe - well, no, it's hardly surprising that this has happened but must be slightly annoying. I'm not enough of a Donkeyboy purist to care and you know you will love it once you see it on the live show!

    Westlife - i need to hear more, but yes it sounded very pleasant indeed :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. RC - i've calmed down a bit. Joe's version is fine. it's just such a crafty steal that I'm not happy :/

    Dwayne - i love your comments!! I do love the X Factor because I wouldn't spend this amount of time on it, but it frustrates me equally as much as it delights me. would I change it though? Probably not :P

    Ben - oh you and Dwayne picked up on the "lets do something camp with them" Diva Fever. I completely missed that because I wanted them to camp it up to!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I just don't have the energy to eloquently articulate why I'm not happy about Joe's "Ambitions," but I'm with you on preferences. This is going to sound contradictory, but for me it's both too close to the original and altered in detracting ways for it to, say, fall into the camp of Shayne's "No Promises." I love Bryan Rice, but Shayne's version of that song is much better in arrangement and vocals (unless we're talking about the Weekend Wonderz mix of Bryan's version, which is surprisingly effective).

    It's also not great that Donkeyboy, co-writers of the song, weren't notified of it being used until news about Joe's release broke on the Internet; even if it's not legally required, it seems like that would have been the "nice" thing to do.

    Still, I hope I'll enjoy the next thing Joe releases more. He even seems like he'd do a lovely job on a traditional ballad, if his version of "No Regrets" is indicative.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I had a feeling you would love Diva Fever... personally they annoyed me, didn't you think it's funny how they had Louis all grey and miserable until they walked out and he bightened up! I'm looking forward to next week, the clip looked very awesome... I saw Cher Lloyd crying--I hope it was tears of happiness. And I saw the Ho of Manchester crying too "I wanna slap myself silly"... well there's no-one stopping you... "it's your life"

    ReplyDelete
  7. PG - I'm even more infuriated that Donkeyboy weren't even aware of this! How bloody rude! I blame SyCo more than joe obviously and will probably investigate his debut album but it feels a bit soured now to be honest!

    Elvin - yeah Diva Fever (should they get through) will definitely be the same diff/jedward of this year! I hope Cher was crying tears of happiness!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Worst audition episode yet...it's only 10 minutes since I watched it, and the only ones that spring to mind are Diva Fever, and that's just because of the name.

    I'm torn by "Ambitions"...I like it, but I don't love it. I think I fall into the same category with this as you fell into with Shayne's new track. Since I don't know the original all that well ("Somebody" has been my Donkeyboy of choice), I might not be coming to the conversation with as much of an opinion. He sure seems to be getting a good amount of support, though. Now let's see if he can get that #1 he was hoping for last year.

    ReplyDelete